Another Victim of the Law: Donald Scott

[SmokeWeed]

On the morning of October 2, 1992, a group of 30 law enforcement officers served a marijuana search warrant to Donald Scott at his Malibu, California ranch. While serving the warrant to Scott and his wife, Frances Plante, deputies shot Scott three times, killing him instantly. No marijuana was found on the property.

In September 1992, a confidential informant told Los Angeles County Sheriff's Deputy Gary Spencer that between 3,000 and 4,000 marijuana plants were being grown on Scott's 200-acre ranch, which was nearly surrounded by state and federal parkland. However, subsequent visits by officials from park rangers, the fish and game service, and law enforcement agents conducting late-night ground surveillance revealed no marijuana on the property. Aerial surveillance by the California Air National Guard yielded inconclusive results.

Finally, only after flying over the property several times, a DEA agent spotted what he thought may have been, at most, 50 marijuana plants. The DEA agent — who did not take pictures or use binoculars during his surveillance — was unwilling to let his observations form the basis of a search warrant without corroboration by another witness. Deputy Spencer told the DEA agent that another confidential informant corroborated his findings, and the agent signed an affadavit that was later used to obtain a search warrant.

The confidential informant later denied having any such conversation with Spencer. In addition, the request for a search warrant made no mention of the officials who saw no marijuana when visiting the property.

On October 2, a group of 30 officers — including members of the Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department, Los Angeles Police Department canine unit, National Guard, National Park Service, U.S. Forest Service, California Bureau of Narcotic Enforcement, and the U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration — gathered at the edge of Scott's ranch and prepared to serve the search warrant. Two of the Sheriff's Department officers were members of the asset forfeiture unit, and researchers from the Jet Propulsion Laboratories in Pasadena were there as well, possibly interested in the use of Scott's ranch in connection with missile testing over the Pacific Ocean.

After pounding on the door and calling out, "Sheriff's department. We have a search warrant. Open the door," Spencer entered Scott's house. Once inside, officers seized Plante. At this point, the story has conflicting versions. Officers swear that Plante was taken outside before the fatal shooting, but Plante says she was in the room when Scott was killed.

Regardless, at some point Scott faced Spencer and another deputy, holding a gun in front of him and pointed upward. The deputies told Scott several times to put his gun down; as he was lowering it, Spencer and the other deputy shot Scott a total of three times. It is unclear if Scott was lowering his weapon to aim at the deputies or if he was going to put it on the ground.

After the fatal shooting, Ventura County District Attorney Michael Bradbury investigated the incident. (Scott's ranch was technically in Ventura County.) Bradbury found that Spencer should never have been granted a search warrant because there was no probable cause to search Scott's property. Controversially, Bradbury also found that the Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department may have been motivated to raid the multi-million-dollar property in order to seize it, as evidenced by the presence of asset forfeiture officers and federal defense researchers at the time of the raid.

Ironically, Frances Plante told Bradbury that Scott was against all drugs and that she had never seen him use marijuana. In January 2000, Plante won a $5 million wrongful death lawsuit against the federal government and Los Angeles County.


Newshawk: *********** - 420 Magazine
Source: Marijuana Policy Project
Copyright: 2006 Marijuana Policy Project
Contact: info@mpp.org
Website: Marijuana Policy Project - Home

[SmokeWeed]

Marijuana does kill......... when you involve the pigs. I haven't called cops 'pigs' for decades but thought it'd be appropriate in this case, actually 'fucking pigs' is the more accurate description.....
Everyone should have a prayer for his brothers and sisters that this doesn't happen to them, nor to you too.......

[HappyKitty]

Aerial surveillence?Searches?

They did all of this because of an informent, who says he never gave them that information. Even if he did tell them, why send 30 people too a home to bust them for something they have no proof of.

If the plants were there, it would be very obvious. They didn't find any! It's hard to miss 3000 plants. If they were removed, there would still be evidence. If someone is watching a harvest, it's not that easy to harvest 3000 plants. What fool would take the chance of growing that much weed on their property?

Aren't you allowed to defend your property? If he had a gun, does anyone really think that he would try to stop 30 people?

I have read too many stories about this type of stuff happening. It's another example of the cops "barking up the wrong tree". I'm glad she sued them. Sadly, she probably will never see it because of legal fees. Someone should have gone down over this...

RIP Mr. Scott. MY concolences Ms Plante.

[Pinch]

Marijuana does kill......... when you involve the pigs. I haven't called cops 'pigs' for decades but thought it'd be appropriate in this case, actually 'fucking pigs' is the more accurate description....

Mr S4L: Very accurate description.

My prayers are with the family.