POLL: Rosenthal Wants A New Trial

[Jim Finnel]

Ed Rosenthal, twice convicted of violating federal drug laws by growing marijuana for medical patients, wants a new trial.

The 62-year-old Oakland man claims U.S. District Judge Charles Breyer in San Francisco wrongly barred him from telling jurors his goal was helping the sick.

In a motion filed earlier this month, Rosenthal's attorney argued Breyer should have allowed him to present evidence regarding "the scientific value of medical marijuana."

Assistant U.S. Attorney George Bevan said Rosenthal's allegations are without merit, according to a motion he filed Wednesday.

A federal jury on May 30 convicted Rosenthal of conspiring to grow and distribute marijuana and other charges. Federal agents in February 2002 seized more than 3,700 pot plants at an Oakland warehouse run by Rosenthal.

He was sentenced to one day in jail, which he'd already served.

Rosenthal was convicted of similar charges in 2003 but an appeals court overturned the verdict because a juror called a lawyer for advice during deliberations.



News Hawk- User 420 MAGAZINE ® - Medical Marijuana Publication & Social Networking
Source: San Francisco Chronicle
Contact: SF Gate: Staff
Copyright: 2007 Hearst Communications Inc.
Website: SAN FRANCISCO / Marijuana grower wants a new trial

 

[Jim Finnel]

i'm not sure how i feel so i haven't voted. i can see sense in both sides. i wondered what all of you think.

 

[Jim Finnel]

so I side with Ed

i think you can side with ed regardless of your position.

for me its a question of best use of energies and resourses. i don't see his cases on main stream media so all that happens is singing to the choir. but i feel his cause is just. i would wonder how is his health, is he strong enough to fight. could the costs of the fight be better use some other way, like bribing politicians. hey, it works for everyone else.

something or some things that are big need to happen. because the people we really need to reach are not getting the message.

 

[Brett2theMax]

Not allowing him to present the scientific information supporting his argument is a violation of his rights, by him not having the ability to use his argument does not give him a fair trial which every person is entitled to in this nation. The government won't allow scientists to research marijuana legally because they know its legit and would look like complete ass hats when everything they have been saying for years is proven 100% false.

 

[Damagoman]

keep up the Strugle!!!

We'll get the jury or judge we want sooner or later!!!!
(with ever election, If we get out and vote)

 

[Jim Finnel]

Not allowing him to present the scientific information supporting his argument is a violation of his rights, by him not having the ability to use his argument does not give him a fair trial which every person is entitled to in this nation. The government won't allow scientists to research marijuana legally because they know its legit and would look like complete ass hats when everything they have been saying for years is proven 100% false.

i agree 100%. i don't question the rightness of his cause.

i'm still not sure. i'm fence stradlin'

 

[Jim Finnel]

its more a states right question in my mind. which is a much more important issue. we've already had a civil war over states rights. thats why there is this problem now. the south should have freed the slaves and then fought over states rights. no i'm not pro-slavery. i am for states rights. ultimately i would be for things to be decided on local levels by popular vote. boy am i rambling. but its all connected. its all the same struggles in different shades of grey. they/we can't admit any medical marijuana testimony into evidence because the darkforce does not recoqnize a states right to decide for itself. this is the sort of thing revolutions have been fought over and blood spilt.

ok, i just talked myself into it. i'm voting to continue the fight. i must be stoned i'm talking to myself, well... and you too.

 

[Damagoman]

Ramble On Buba.
( I gota' sit upnow, and type with both fingers)
The more that do listen The Stronger WE beCome !!!

The Divided Hemp States of America

States have no rights, only CommonWealths do.

that right?

 

[Jim Finnel]

commonwealths have rights?

 

[Damagoman]

More than a State
or are suppose to ...

I think ...
were did I dump that txt,
looked it up once and saved it, defintion of commonwealth

 

[Pinch]

Ed has absolutely nothing to lose and everything to gain by continuing his legal right to have his day in court.. another day that is.

Kudos for Ed!

 

[Smokin Moose]

I'm on the fence on this one as well. One question I ask myself is "where do the profits from his grows go?"

 

[Pinch]

I don't think that's the point Mr Moose. Ed has a legitimate federal soap box to preach from.. I say, "Let him do it, power to him".

Neither here nor there, he gets to fuck with federal prosecutors and indirectly, the DEA while carrying a "get-out-of-jail-free card". I cannot imagine what could be more fun.

 

[Smokin Moose]

^ good point Pinch. Thank you.

 

[Pinch]

^ good point Pinch. Thank you.

Thanks for your comment.

P.S.: I don't mind seeing my tax dollars spent on cases like this. It generates great "world" press for the Medical Cannabis cause.

 

[Jim Finnel]

he gets to fuck with federal prosecutors and indirectly, the DEA while carrying a "get-out-of-jail-free card". I cannot imagine what could be more fun

when you put it that way i can't think of a better reason for him to keep it up. fucking with them makes sense to me.

 

[Pinch]

Thanks Mr U. Yeah, makes sense, doesn't it?

Here's some interesting reading..

Obscure Store and Reading Room: Pot advocate gets just a day in jail, but still lectures judge

 

[Pinch]

Please check out this interview with ED and his attorneys and supporters.

May Everyday Be Green! - ed rosenthal part 2



Six million dollars in taxpayers money to date.

 

[Ugodmade]

I wish my dad was here he could tell you all about ed .. I don't know much about him .. only that he knows his Cannabis even a Nobel piece winer for it i think

 

[Smokin Moose]

^Rosenthal has never won a Nobel prize.