Oregon's 32,929 medical marijuana users can't be denied concealed handgun licenses, despite the efforts of at least two sheriffs who want to keep concealed weapons out of those hands.
The Oregon Court of Appeals ruled this week that Washington County Sheriff Rob Gordon and Jackson County Sheriff Mike Winters were mistaken in their interpretation of the federal Gun Control Act. The act states that "an unlawful user ... of any controlled substance" can't own a gun, and the sheriffs contended the federal act trumps Oregon's medical marijuana law. Though federal law prohibits marijuana, Oregon's 12-year-old law legalizes pot possession for patients with qualifying ailments and a doctor's approval.
Leland Berger, who represented four medical marijuana users who were denied concealed handgun licenses, was relieved by the Court of Appeals decision. He sees the sheriffs' denial of licenses as discrimination against patients who use cannabis to treat debilitating health problems -- including cancer, glaucoma, seizures, nausea and severe pain.
"They are opposed to the law generally, and this is how they express their opposition to the law," Berger said, adding that fighting the cases was expensive for the counties. "The downside is it's a huge waste of taxpayer resources."
Elmer Dickens, who argued the case for the Washington County sheriff, took offense at Berger's characterization.
"We absolutely don't think this has anything to do with discrimination," Dickens said. "And frankly, he's impugning the integrity of every sheriff in the state."
Dickens said Washington County was the first in the state to ask applicants seeking concealed gun licenses whether they use medical marijuana and to deny those who said yes. He said sheriffs in many other counties -- including Coos and Douglas -- followed, seeing Washington County's logic: that sheriffs are sworn to enforce the law and federal law forbids pot smokers from possessing guns.
Multnomah County asks applicants the same question, but a sheriff's employee who handles applications said medical marijuana users aren't denied licenses. Clackamas County doesn't ask. State law doesn't direct counties to do so.
Washington County hasn't decided whether to appeal to the Oregon Supreme Court. Sheriff Gordon is on vacation and couldn't be reached for comment. Douglas County Sheriff Winters also couldn't be reached for comment.
At the center of the case is Steve Schwerdt, who used marijuana and other medications for debilitating back and knee pain that is so bad he sometimes can't walk. Washington County denied him a concealed handgun renewal, he fought it, and in 2005 Circuit Judge Marco Hernandez ruled in his favor -- a county attorney says because he couldn't prove Schwerdt actually owned a gun. Washington County later pulled Schwerdt's license, Schwerdt went to court again, and Circuit Judge Steven Price ruled in favor of Schwerdt and two other cannabis cardholders.
The county turned to the Court of Appeals.
"I'm getting tired of having to go through this over and over again," Schwerdt said.
Schwerdt said he feels as if the sheriff has put him in the same category as ****** addicts.
"The first time around I sat there and felt like I was a junkie," Schwerdt said. "They treat you like you're something that you're not -- a criminal and the sort. And I'm not."
Although medical marijuana users who practice the Second Amendment celebrated the appellate ruling, their legal standing remains unclear.
In April, the Oregon Supreme Court ruled that medical marijuana users can be fired for drug use. Specifically, in overturning a Court of Appeals ruling, the high court said federal law requiring employers to accommodate disabled workers doesn't cover medical marijuana users.
Adding to the murkiness, the Obama administration last year told federal authorities not to arrest or prosecute medical marijuana users. A tally at the time showed 14 states, including Washington and California, allowed some medical marijuana use.
The Oregon Firearms Federation has no problem with medical marijuana cardholders carrying concealed weapons -- or for that matter, any law-abiding citizen, said federation director Kevin Starrett.
NewsHawk: Ganjarden: 420 MAGAZINE
Source: OregonLive.com
Author: Aimee Green
Contact: OregonLive.com
Copyright: 2010 Oregon Live LLC
Website: Oregon Court of Appeals gun ruling a victory for medical marijuana users
* Thanks to MedicalNeed for submitting this article
The Oregon Court of Appeals ruled this week that Washington County Sheriff Rob Gordon and Jackson County Sheriff Mike Winters were mistaken in their interpretation of the federal Gun Control Act. The act states that "an unlawful user ... of any controlled substance" can't own a gun, and the sheriffs contended the federal act trumps Oregon's medical marijuana law. Though federal law prohibits marijuana, Oregon's 12-year-old law legalizes pot possession for patients with qualifying ailments and a doctor's approval.
Leland Berger, who represented four medical marijuana users who were denied concealed handgun licenses, was relieved by the Court of Appeals decision. He sees the sheriffs' denial of licenses as discrimination against patients who use cannabis to treat debilitating health problems -- including cancer, glaucoma, seizures, nausea and severe pain.
"They are opposed to the law generally, and this is how they express their opposition to the law," Berger said, adding that fighting the cases was expensive for the counties. "The downside is it's a huge waste of taxpayer resources."
Elmer Dickens, who argued the case for the Washington County sheriff, took offense at Berger's characterization.
"We absolutely don't think this has anything to do with discrimination," Dickens said. "And frankly, he's impugning the integrity of every sheriff in the state."
Dickens said Washington County was the first in the state to ask applicants seeking concealed gun licenses whether they use medical marijuana and to deny those who said yes. He said sheriffs in many other counties -- including Coos and Douglas -- followed, seeing Washington County's logic: that sheriffs are sworn to enforce the law and federal law forbids pot smokers from possessing guns.
Multnomah County asks applicants the same question, but a sheriff's employee who handles applications said medical marijuana users aren't denied licenses. Clackamas County doesn't ask. State law doesn't direct counties to do so.
Washington County hasn't decided whether to appeal to the Oregon Supreme Court. Sheriff Gordon is on vacation and couldn't be reached for comment. Douglas County Sheriff Winters also couldn't be reached for comment.
At the center of the case is Steve Schwerdt, who used marijuana and other medications for debilitating back and knee pain that is so bad he sometimes can't walk. Washington County denied him a concealed handgun renewal, he fought it, and in 2005 Circuit Judge Marco Hernandez ruled in his favor -- a county attorney says because he couldn't prove Schwerdt actually owned a gun. Washington County later pulled Schwerdt's license, Schwerdt went to court again, and Circuit Judge Steven Price ruled in favor of Schwerdt and two other cannabis cardholders.
The county turned to the Court of Appeals.
"I'm getting tired of having to go through this over and over again," Schwerdt said.
Schwerdt said he feels as if the sheriff has put him in the same category as ****** addicts.
"The first time around I sat there and felt like I was a junkie," Schwerdt said. "They treat you like you're something that you're not -- a criminal and the sort. And I'm not."
Although medical marijuana users who practice the Second Amendment celebrated the appellate ruling, their legal standing remains unclear.
In April, the Oregon Supreme Court ruled that medical marijuana users can be fired for drug use. Specifically, in overturning a Court of Appeals ruling, the high court said federal law requiring employers to accommodate disabled workers doesn't cover medical marijuana users.
Adding to the murkiness, the Obama administration last year told federal authorities not to arrest or prosecute medical marijuana users. A tally at the time showed 14 states, including Washington and California, allowed some medical marijuana use.
The Oregon Firearms Federation has no problem with medical marijuana cardholders carrying concealed weapons -- or for that matter, any law-abiding citizen, said federation director Kevin Starrett.
NewsHawk: Ganjarden: 420 MAGAZINE
Source: OregonLive.com
Author: Aimee Green
Contact: OregonLive.com
Copyright: 2010 Oregon Live LLC
Website: Oregon Court of Appeals gun ruling a victory for medical marijuana users
* Thanks to MedicalNeed for submitting this article
